Expression Engine Re-visit
Sometimes ago, I talked about my view towards Expression Engine.
Time rolling forward until May, 2007. I am now determining on how to setup the community site for CECID, which we expect it will be
The challenge is, are the a single platform that serve it all?
My first reaction is to consider about Wordpress, the tools I am most familiar with. It is easy to setup, quite extensible (due to the availability of plugin and templates) but it only shines in a single perspective - Blogging. It will be difficult to integrate other features, especially on how to share a single user account across the different function.
So, a no go. Next, Drupal and Joomla comes up in mind.
I have tried Drupal quite extensively before, when I was setting up this blog. I remember how tedious it is in both configuration and content publishing. I can't even spot out the route on how to do every thing. The admin panel is messy in short.
Joomla, it has the functions required and provide rooms for the administrator to configure the look and feel. Customization can be done, yet, it's not intuitive. I don't have much interest to try out again, but might consider to take a second look at it.
And EE pops up in mind again. Headed over to their new homepage (http://ellislab.com/) and noticed about the new look. Gone through the 4 video tutorial in illustrating the main concept of EE (especially the templating system) and I can grasp their templating idea. Like why it is done this way and the strength of the architecture.
They provided the forum module with a single user database, too. So, it matches functionality. What I have done next is to apply for a trial account, allowing me to try out their templating system, forum module and such. Their templating system is very powerful, the content aggregation and look of the website can be designed with ease, it is a very nice MVC implementation. Imagine, you can customize the layout of the homepage in HTML, but you have provided additional tag that allows logical operation in building up the page.
For instance, I can define the homepage to show the latest forum post summary on the right hand side, and only show the summary of each blog entry in reverse chronological order. I can even pass in arguments which the tag can understand, e.g. the number of entry to show, etc.
The content of the website can be defined into groups, e.g. product group, download group, etc. For each group, we can define the look and feel individually. I have spoted a nice layout from the Open Source Web Design web page, and have it applied to the "Product" section.
Administration and installation is also a breeze, you post the article, configure the server all in one place. The layout makes much more sense and you can decide to turn on or off certain features as you see fit.
With all these features, I am sold, but there's a downside. It is not a free software.
They offered 2 types of license, basically one for commercial and one is not. I checked with them and they said we can use the non-commercial license. This license, together with the forum module, cost the centre for about HK$1200. I would say it is reasonably charged.
Now, what's left are the building of the Information Architecture, and also the templates that will be used in the forum module.
For anyone of interest, head over to Expression Engine and get a copy of Core Edition, which is for non-profit and personal use. It has provided the templating engine already.
Time rolling forward until May, 2007. I am now determining on how to setup the community site for CECID, which we expect it will be
partly a blog, partly a forum with user activity, some static pages for file downloading purposes.
The challenge is, are the a single platform that serve it all?
Can my old mate help me out?
My first reaction is to consider about Wordpress, the tools I am most familiar with. It is easy to setup, quite extensible (due to the availability of plugin and templates) but it only shines in a single perspective - Blogging. It will be difficult to integrate other features, especially on how to share a single user account across the different function.
So, a no go. Next, Drupal and Joomla comes up in mind.
Time to think alternative
I have tried Drupal quite extensively before, when I was setting up this blog. I remember how tedious it is in both configuration and content publishing. I can't even spot out the route on how to do every thing. The admin panel is messy in short.
Joomla, it has the functions required and provide rooms for the administrator to configure the look and feel. Customization can be done, yet, it's not intuitive. I don't have much interest to try out again, but might consider to take a second look at it.
Can we have a second chance?
And EE pops up in mind again. Headed over to their new homepage (http://ellislab.com/) and noticed about the new look. Gone through the 4 video tutorial in illustrating the main concept of EE (especially the templating system) and I can grasp their templating idea. Like why it is done this way and the strength of the architecture.
They provided the forum module with a single user database, too. So, it matches functionality. What I have done next is to apply for a trial account, allowing me to try out their templating system, forum module and such. Their templating system is very powerful, the content aggregation and look of the website can be designed with ease, it is a very nice MVC implementation. Imagine, you can customize the layout of the homepage in HTML, but you have provided additional tag that allows logical operation in building up the page.
A powerful templating system
For instance, I can define the homepage to show the latest forum post summary on the right hand side, and only show the summary of each blog entry in reverse chronological order. I can even pass in arguments which the tag can understand, e.g. the number of entry to show, etc.
The content of the website can be defined into groups, e.g. product group, download group, etc. For each group, we can define the look and feel individually. I have spoted a nice layout from the Open Source Web Design web page, and have it applied to the "Product" section.
Administration and installation is also a breeze, you post the article, configure the server all in one place. The layout makes much more sense and you can decide to turn on or off certain features as you see fit.
There's always a but ...
With all these features, I am sold, but there's a downside. It is not a free software.
They offered 2 types of license, basically one for commercial and one is not. I checked with them and they said we can use the non-commercial license. This license, together with the forum module, cost the centre for about HK$1200. I would say it is reasonably charged.
Now, what's left are the building of the Information Architecture, and also the templates that will be used in the forum module.
For anyone of interest, head over to Expression Engine and get a copy of Core Edition, which is for non-profit and personal use. It has provided the templating engine already.